How to Order Cupcakes:
1.) Pick out your flavors, you must order at least 6 cupcakes per flavor for special orders or you can request assorted at any time. Cupcakes are $3.00 each.
2. Give us a call at (317) 939-2957, and order! Do not email orders or send via social media channels.
Special orders require a minimum of three days notice. If you are past the 3 days cut off, you can still order "assorted" which would be a mixture of what cupcakes we make fresh that day. We make a different assortment of cupcakes each day. You can also call the day before or day of to see what we have in the case and pick from those flavors.
Any of the flavors with ** next to it can be made gluten free!
​
We are not a GF certified facility.
​
Lemon
Lemon lovers
Lemon blueberry
Strawberry
Strawberry lemonade
Strawberry shortcake*
Strawberry sugar cookie
Chocolate salted caramel*
Chocolate*
Yellow*
Vanilla
White
Sugar cookie*
Peanut butter cookie
Snowball (chocolate with coconut)*
Cookies and cream
Cookie Monster
Mint Oreo
PB Oreo
Peanut butter banana
Turtle*
S'more
Birthday cake*
Dreamsicle*
Snickerdoodle*
Salted caramel*
Chocolate peanut butter*
Carrot cake
Cookie dough
Mint choc chip
Wedding cake
Banana pancake
Neapolitan
Snickers
Toffee crunch*
Red velvet
Red velvet Oreo
Hot fudge sundae*
Double fudge*
Double fudge Oreo
Worms and dirt (kids cupcake)
The Hayloft (white cake, peanut butter icing, chocolate sauce and caramel sauce)*
Spice cake
Yellow cake with fudge*
Cinnamon roll*
Butter pecan caramel
Caramel macchiato
Mocha chip
French toast
Margarita
Strawberry margarita
Blueberry cobbler
Pistachio
Caramel apple
Apple pie
Double fudge salted caramel*
Brownie (buttercream, mint, peanut butter, double fudge, salted caramel)*
Almond Joy
Pumpkin spice (fall)
Pumpkin snickerdoodle (fall)
Pumpkin cinnamon roll (fall)
Pumpkin mudslide (fall)
Peppermint mocha (winter/Christmas)
Hot chocolate (winter)
Chocolate candy cane (winter/Christmas)
Peppermint bark (winter/Christmas)
Peppermint hot cocoa (winter/Christmas)
Irish cream (vanilla or chocolate)
​
Don't see what you're looking for? Make sure to pre order and ask about creating a flavor. Due to covid, we are limited on some ingredients.
​